ornithologist: (006)
Harold Finch ([personal profile] ornithologist) wrote in [community profile] etrayalogs2025-03-22 10:05 am

I won't run, the guilt is mine

WHO: Harold Finch & established CR
WHEN: Forward dated post-mission
WHERE: Around Etraya
WHAT: Harold canon updates to post-series and has a bit of a time. Closed starters below. There will be an open post for him after these are sorted through!
NOTES\WARNINGS: This whole post and all threads are full of descriptions of grieving and suicidal thoughts & ideation.

After it happens, after he recovers his memories of how everything fell apart, Harold questions his grip on reality. It would be appropriate if after all this time he finally met his limit. John is dead and Root is dead and Elias is dead and-- the Machine is dead-- and Grace is alive, but what right does he have to see her, how can he get a happy ending when he's the one who deserves it the least--

He's in the library they abandoned long ago and there's traces of his life here with John all around him. Rationally, intellectually, he knows where he is. This is Etraya. He can reread their text conversations, few though they were, and reassure himself that this is real and that this is happening. But there's no one here. It's eerie, everyone away on the mission; it's like Harold is in some kind of bizarre tortuous stasis. He's here but no one else is, survivor's guilt made manifest in its natural apotheosis.

He finds the remnants of all the projects he'd been working on so steadily what must've been a day ago, electronic pieces strewn around and multiple computers chugging test code, and stares at them. They seem so pointless now. Meaningless. Harold struggles to find an ounce of caring in his soul, for anyone, for anything. Surveillance? A covert encrypted network?

What does it matter? He's utterly alone.

Harold can't stay there. The numbness is getting increasingly punctured every time he finds something John left behind: washed dishes from making him dinner, a suit jacket left over the back of a chair, and then Bear himself. He has to leave the library or risk feeling things again and that's a tidal wave whose potential aftermath frightens him.

Mutely, he leashes Bear and heads out, and for hours he wanders the empty streets of Etraya, wondering how much longer he has to endure existence.
aimsforknees: (158)

[personal profile] aimsforknees 2025-04-13 02:07 am (UTC)(link)
[ Of course if Harold was asking in the first place he wouldn't let John get away with such a shallow answer. He looks at the eggs in the pan almost blindly, pushes them around in an automatic way. He know what he needs to say but it's terrifying. It's the truth again but it's going to scare Harold away. He's going to be left alone in his apartment with these pancakes and bacon and eggs. ]

I'm dead. And I don't know what to do. And— [ his throat closes up on the words but he forces them out anyways] I hurt you.

[ That last part matters. He has no clue what to do about it, but it matters so much to him. He's grappled with the image of Harold crying every day. It hurts to think about again and again. He did that. Even in the depths of his drunkenness, even in the moments he can't really remember, he was aware of how he hurt Harold, how he said the wrong thing, how alone he felt in his apartment. ]
aimsforknees: (162)

[personal profile] aimsforknees 2025-04-13 02:41 am (UTC)(link)
[ He doesn't know what to say to that, so he busies himself with the breakfast instead. The plates are already out, all he has to do is scrape half the eggs on each plate and pull the bacon and pancakes from where they're warm in the oven.

He doesn't know what to say. ]


I can't take that back. And I don't know how to comfort you. I'm sorry, for that. I hope you have friends who can. Who did.

[ John wishes he knew how. He wishes he knew the right thing to say. He wishes he could ease Harold's pain, not just so that they could return to how things were, but because he doesn't like to think about Harold hurting. He hopes people like Maria were able to help Harold the way she helped him.

But he doesn't apologize for dying because not matter how much it hurt Harold, no matter how much it hurts himself, he wouldn't do anything differently. Even knowing the path they're on, even if Harold walks away forever, he'll still be alive back home. The one life that really matters. It's just, he didn't think there would be anything after for him. He didn't think it would matter. He didn't have time to think about how Harold would feel about it, or maybe he did and it didn't occur to him; he was just so focused on Harold living to really think about what that life would be like. And now he's faced with his own uncertainty and realizes he created a scenario where that was always going to be the outcome for Harold, both in Etraya and back home. ]


I don't think I understand what it means to you. Will you tell me?

[ It feels like a lot to ask of Harold, but he wants to know. If they're actually having this conversation he wants to understand. ]
aimsforknees: (139)

[personal profile] aimsforknees 2025-04-14 05:36 pm (UTC)(link)
[ It's easier when Harold is talking to look at him, so John lifts his gaze from the plates with rapidly cooling eggs. He just tries to listen, to not immediately get wrapped up in whatever Harold is saying and speak before he's really ready to say anything. There is no right answer, there is no perfect thing that will solve all this, so he needs to be careful; it feels like at any moment they'll just crack and fracture again and Harold will walk out the door.

So, comforting is off the table for both of them. John doesn't know what it would even look like for someone to comfort him, least of all from Harold. Comfort has been the last thing from his mind all these years, it's completely foreign now.

But beside that— he feels all too closely Harold's words. It hurts to hear him say that he didn't want to outlive the numbers. Of course John wants Harold to live, has gone to great lengths for Harold to live, but it wasn't at all what Harold wanted. But can John say any different about himself? If it had been the other way around, if Harold had given him a second chance, would he have been able to accept it? But he's forced Harold to do just that, has forced him to live without that something more than just the mission as well.

It's painful to speak but John makes the words come out, forces them through his closed up throat. ]


We did. It was more than just the mission.

[ John doesn't think he'd survive being turned down so he just thinks desperately to himself, Of course it was more, I love you. His heart is hammering and pounding and it's so painful and loud, but he holds his hand out to Harold. He hopes Harold will see it for what it is, sees it as John stepping into that space they never talked about; friends, but John is greedy for so much more than that. ]

I'm sorry for never trying to talk to you. I'm not good at it, but that's not an excuse, is it?

[ Fusco taught him that. Fusco taught him that he can't just go taking everything for granted, can't just leave everything unsaid, and that's exactly what he did anyway. ]
aimsforknees: (118)

[personal profile] aimsforknees 2025-04-14 07:40 pm (UTC)(link)
[ Harold takes his hand, Harold says how important you are to me and John feels something unclench in his chest. There's still the fear there that he will say the wrong thing, do the wrong thing, he still feels he needs to be careful, but there is something so solid about Harold's words, Harold's actions. He feels like he can take a deep breath all of a sudden, can fill his lungs out. John holds his hand tightly in return. ]

I said it's because your life is the right life, but it was always more than that.

[ It has been for so long. It feels like a lifetime ago that Harold wasn't the pillar of his life, wasn't the thing he orbits around. If they'd had this conversation earlier, if he'd known how much Harold thinks of him, if he'd known Harold would hold his hand tightly like this, what would he have done instead? What would he have said instead? ]

Working with you was the only thing that kept me going, it wasn't just a job. It wasn't just the mission. It's because you were there.

[ There's a moment before he adds, quiet and a little hesitant, ]

Living with you here in the library has been one of the best things that's happened in my life.

[ It's a confession, of sorts, part of the truth but not giving away the whole thing. It's not telling Harold how he wasn't willing to live without him by his side, which John realizes is not a thing he should say despite it being the truth. It's not telling Harold that he loves him, which is still something John isn't sure he deserves. Etraya has been a trial in many ways, but it's given John something he'd only dreamed of. He doesn't mean it accusatory that Harold left, that Harold walked away, and he hopes Harold doesn't take it that way; he understands better why Harold had to leave. Maybe he should clarify that, not leave the ambiguity now. ]

But I think I understand why you left, at least some.

[ As Maria said, they both needed time. ]
aimsforknees: (139)

[personal profile] aimsforknees 2025-04-16 04:58 pm (UTC)(link)
[ It feels like there's no shortage of things John could do to protest, could bring up as counter arguments to Harold's declaration, not the least of which is that he has no clue what life and living in Etraya looks like. What he'll even do with this opportunity. But he's also certain Harold has thought through all of that, he's never anything but thorough when making decisions and that's why John trusts him wholeheartedly. So if Harold says that's what he wants, there's nothing for John to protest or doubt. ]

I didn't really want to leave you in the first place. I didn't want it to be over.

[ It's a realization he's come to slowly, a painful one. He didn't really want to die, it was just better than the alternative in his mind. He didn't want to leave the tenuous life he fell into with Harold, with everyone. He's... sad that it's over, that he'll never walk around New York City by Harold's side again. ]

I don't know what living long term in Etraya looks like, but I want to do it with you. So, yes.
aimsforknees: (67)

[personal profile] aimsforknees 2025-04-16 06:48 pm (UTC)(link)
[ Harold seems to care very much about John's declaration about his death, where John had been worried it would upset him again. He's not entirely sure it hasn't, but it hasn't driven Harold away. At the very least Harold has doubled down on staying here with him, which is all John really wants in the end. ]

I don't know what living just to live is like anymore, [ he confesses, almost a bit sadly. He's had enough distance, enough learning opportunities to realize at least in part how much his path has hurt him. ]

But I'm willing to try. I guess I'll have a long time to learn. And I want to help people here, too. As long as there are missions, as long as there's worlds that need saving.

[ In Etraya, a place without death, there's no escape from this life. It will go on and on. He'll probably get to die of old age, something he hasn't thought possible since he entered the Army, a lifetime ago. But if he gets to spend what's rest of his life with Harold then it will be worth it. After all they've been through over the years, John has realized he doesn't have to be alone; he isn't alone. More than just Harold, he has the whole team, and Shaw said she wanted to stay here too. ]
aimsforknees: (139)

[personal profile] aimsforknees 2025-04-19 03:35 am (UTC)(link)
[ The thing that brought them together in the first place, the thing that brought John back from Italy, the thing that meant he could never leave Harold to just be Professor Whistler, was this purpose. This belief that they should be helping others. The years have only made John more committed to it. ]

I don't think we can help the worlds without helping people. We're not alone here. When we first arrived I didn't fully agree that this wasn't going to end up a competition, but I don't believe that now. We're all in this together, we have to help each other out.

[ He believed that before he regained his memories and his time at home hasn't changed that one bit. He has friends here, in all shapes and sizes and ages. Gorgug who he's going to fish with, Shadowheart who he baked a pie with, even Carver who probably doesn't really trust him. These are not people he could ever lift a hand against, he will always find another way. He will always walk that path with Harold, and if he feels he's lost the way he'll just follow Harold's footsteps; that's what he'd meant by the right life. ]
aimsforknees: (67)

[personal profile] aimsforknees 2025-04-20 03:40 am (UTC)(link)
[ He can see what Harold is getting at, what Harold believes. It's not really about those far away worlds at all, the big decisions, the grand vision for the future. Harold is just talking about the here and now, the people in front of them, the people living in this apartment building and also the people who have found their homes outside of it. Just helping them.

And helping them without the Machine's guidance, without her hand. He didn't get to talk with her much, even on the rooftop it was a very one sided conversation where she made sure he wasn't alone, and he regrets that. They shared so many moments over the years. He's sure Harold misses her much, much more. ]


It hasn't. No one is irrelevant. I can't promise I won't think of those worlds out there, but I won't sacrifice the people here for them. I'll fight to find a way to save them both.

[ And he doesn't doubt Harold will help him if he needs it. He doesn't even ask. But it's impossible for him to not think of all those lives at stake. In a way this is what he always wanted to do, to fight to save the world. He joined the Army and the CIA thinking he could get an opportunity at that, thinking he could do some good for his country. And now he has a chance to do something bigger than that, not just for his own world but for others as well. John agrees with Harold that they have to save the people in front of them, but he can't lose sight of the larger goal as well, it's a dream that exists in the marrow of his bones. ]
aimsforknees: (118)

[personal profile] aimsforknees 2025-04-21 06:37 pm (UTC)(link)
[ John wants to protest that, to say that he's not a good man. He's crossed so many lines, how could he be? But Harold believes it, and John trusts Harold. It feels impossible to accept, but he doesn't challenge it, thinks of another way to say what he means. He doesn't want to upset Harold, who this clearly means a lot to. He doesn't think he could stand to see Harold cry again, doesn't really understand what his tearfulness means in this moment. ]

I've done so many terrible things, Harold. I let myself do them. But you asked me to be better than that, gave me a chance to do good things instead. [ He thinks of the senator, how Harold was the one voice of reason in the room, how they all followed him. ] I know I can trust you, follow you. I guess we helped each other. I wouldn't be here without you.

[ If Harold says that he's a better person because of John, he won't refute that. He can't put those words in Harold's mouth even if he doesn't understand how they're true. ]
aimsforknees: (133)

[personal profile] aimsforknees 2025-04-21 10:10 pm (UTC)(link)
[ Harold is suddenly near, suddenly there, and John is frozen for a moment where he doesn't know what to do— but then he gently wraps his arms around Harold's shoulders. It's a loose gesture, almost unsure. Is he allowed to have this? Harold doesn't know his feelings, doesn't know that John has longed for this. If he returns this gesture in full, is that deception? Is that a lie of omission?

But John is weak and full of longing and pain so he wraps his arms tighter around Harold. Lets himself feel Harold's warmth, the texture of his suit under his hands. Engraves the shape of Harold into his mind. He may never get this again and he's so greedy for it, he has to etch every part of this moment in his memory.

There's nothing for him to say, because anything he could say would be a damning admission of how much he loves Harold, how full his heart is in this moment. The want, the sadness, the joy. He will let this moment last as long as Harold will allow. ]
aimsforknees: (139)

[personal profile] aimsforknees 2025-04-26 01:57 am (UTC)(link)
[ Harold stays longer than John expects. He thinks any moment now that Harold will pull away and yet he stays moment after moment and John just... lets it happen. He doesn't think about what it means, he just holds Harold. He died just over a week ago, he shouldn't get to have this, he died and then fell apart completely, but here is Harold still. Here is Harold by his side, in his arms, Harold who never gave up on him, not before and not this time. Harold who still came to see him morning after painful morning when he didn't want to see John at all.

But Harold does pull away eventually and John lets him go. He immediately wants Harold back, wants him in his arms again, but he restrains himself, tells himself he shouldn't be too greedy. It has to be enough that he got it once.

Harold in the aftermath is sure and steady in the way that John is familiar with. Whatever he has grappled with, whatever decisions he has made, he has settled on them for good. If he says that he killed the Machine then yes, he must have decided that. John doesn't know all the details, so if Harold says that, John won't refute. The Machine is dead, that much is undeniable. They died together on that rooftop. John wonders briefly how she feels about her own death, whether it was one she was satisfied with. Whether she wanted to live longer. Unlike John, she won't get a chance to tell anyone.

Unlike John, who will get to stay in Etraya with Harold. Is it selfish for Harold to stay? John doesn't think so, but he's not about to tell Harold how to feel about it. They've gone over this already but John still feels immense relief when Harold says he's staying, relief followed up by so much love. It feels overwhelming, like it might just burst out of his chest if he breathes wrong. In this moment he's so close to that feeling, and closer to losing control of it than ever before. John reaches across the distance and smooths the shoulder of Harold's suit, feels the wool beneath his hands, the warmth of Harold beneath. A gesture to bleed off some of that feeling, a way to keep himself from saying anything unwise. Harold wants to stay with him, what more could he ask for? ]


Regardless of what rules you broke, you're still the person I've chosen to follow, to be with. I won't choose to leave you again.

[ Choose, because Echo might have plans that John is powerless to stop, but he understands now what it means to Harold. Next time—if there is a next time—he'll make sure to talk with Harold before making any decisions. ]
aimsforknees: (62 (r))

[personal profile] aimsforknees 2025-04-30 09:30 pm (UTC)(link)
[ John recognizes it for what it is: asking but not asking, an offer but room for him to back out if he wants; Harold is asking but not pushing. It's like that between them now, they've reached an equilibrium over the years where they rarely double down; is the last time when John didn't let Harold back out of the numbers?

But here is Harold holding his hands, here is Harold offering him everything he's wanted. He gives just the hint of a smile, something that feels foreign after his recent mood, but it slips out nonetheless. He tightens his hands in Harold's grasp ever so slightly as he speaks. ]


Yes. [ Honesty, honesty. It takes effort but he can no longer take their relationship for granted given the past week. Given that he's dead. ] That's all I really wanted.

[ Is that too honest? Too forward? Is he giving away too much? Can Harold see how much his life has hinged on what's between them? Others have come and sometimes gone, have left imprints on him, have even driven him from Harold, from this purpose that brought them together, but at the core there has always been Harold. The beginning and the end. Harold gave him a life and John returned it; he can see now that it wasn't a debt but a gift. Harold gives everything freely, and John spent it how he wanted, selfishly.

And now they have taken a step forward, a step closer. This commitment to stay together. It's not the full extent of John's feelings, but it's enough. It's enough. Harold is holding his hands, Harold is returning to the closeness they shared in the library, Harold won't leave him. He got to hold Harold and when he reached for Harold again he didn't let John go. John could not ask for more. ]

(no subject)

[personal profile] aimsforknees - 2025-05-04 19:47 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] aimsforknees - 2025-05-12 00:04 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] aimsforknees - 2025-05-16 18:47 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] aimsforknees - 2025-05-31 00:28 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] aimsforknees - 2025-06-03 02:38 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] aimsforknees - 2025-06-08 21:38 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] aimsforknees - 2025-06-12 03:40 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] aimsforknees - 2025-06-14 03:37 (UTC) - Expand